Can You 1031 Exchange Into Property in Another State?
Some of the largest exchanges I handle are New Yorkers and Californians moving equity to Texas, Florida, Wyoming, or Tennessee. The federal rules don't care about state lines. The states do, and each one has its own way of caring.
- Real property anywhere in the United States is like-kind with real property anywhere else in the United States. State-to-state exchanges are routine.
- Many states withhold estimated tax from nonresident sellers at closing; exchanges are exempt, but you must file the exemption form before closing or fight for a refund.
- California, Oregon, Montana, and Massachusetts track gain that leaves the state and tax it when you eventually sell for cash. Everywhere else, the gain follows the property.
- The end-state matters: the state where your final property sits (and where you live) is the one that taxes the accumulated gain, unless a clawback applies.
The federal side: nothing changes
Section 1031 treats all U.S. real property as like-kind with all other U.S. real property. A Brooklyn brownstone for a Nashville fourplex, Los Angeles apartments for a Phoenix warehouse, Chicago retail for a Wyoming ranch: all fine. The only geographic exclusion is foreign real estate, which is not like-kind with U.S. property (IRC §1031(h)). The 45/180-day rules, the intermediary requirement, and Form 8824 are identical. Two closings in two states just means two sets of local counsel.
Withholding at the sale closing
Many states require the buyer or closing agent to withhold a percentage of the sale price from nonresident sellers as a prepayment of state income tax. California withholds 3⅓% of the price, Hawaii 7.25% under HARPTA, New Jersey collects estimated tax through its GIT/REP forms, New York requires nonresidents to file IT-2663, and Maryland, South Carolina, Georgia, Colorado, Vermont, Rhode Island, West Virginia, and Maine have their own versions.
All of them exempt 1031 exchanges, because there's no gain to prepay tax on. But the exemption is claimed by filing a form before or at closing (California Form 593, Hawaii N-289, New Jersey GIT/REP-3, and so on). Miss it and the closing agent withholds anyway, and you're chasing a refund from a state revenue department while your exchange funds are short. Put the withholding form on the pre-closing checklist.
Clawback states
In most states, once you exchange out, the state is done with you. Four states keep score. California requires Form FTB 3840 every year until the deferred gain is recognized, and taxes the California-sourced portion when you finally sell for cash, even if you've lived in Texas for a decade. Oregon, Montana, and Massachusetts have similar tracking or clawback provisions. The California rule and the strategies around it are in how California's clawback works. Note that a clawback taxes only the gain that accrued while the property was in that state, not appreciation after you left.
Which state taxes you at the end
When you eventually sell for cash, the gain is taxed by the state where the property is located and, if different, the state where you reside (with a credit for tax paid to the property state). Exchange out of New York into Florida property while living in Florida, and the accumulated federal-deferred gain is taxed by nobody at the state level when you sell, because New York has no clawback. Do the same from California and California still wants its share of the California-era gain. Compare the stakes in the state tax rate table.
The practical side of buying far away
- Identify early. Out-of-state searches take longer. Have a broker in the target market engaged before your sale closes, not after.
- Management. A property you can't drive to needs a manager you trust. Price that into the return.
- Title and closing customs differ. Attorney states versus escrow states, different survey and inspection norms, different deed types. Local counsel is not optional.
- DSTs are inherently multi-state. A Delaware Statutory Trust interest lets you hold institutional property in several states without managing any of them; the ones I work with are zero-cash-flow structures, which suits investors whose goal is equity preservation rather than income.
- Transfer taxes. Some jurisdictions charge stiff transfer or mansion taxes on the purchase side. Budget for them.
Every state's specifics, including withholding and conformity, are on the state-by-state pages.
Frequently asked questions
Can you do a 1031 exchange from one state to another?
Yes. All U.S. real property is like-kind with all other U.S. real property under federal law. State-to-state exchanges are common; only foreign property is excluded.
Do I pay state tax when I 1031 exchange out of a state?
Generally no, because nearly every state conforms to Section 1031. California, Oregon, Montana, and Massachusetts track the deferred gain and tax it when you eventually sell for cash.
Will the state withhold tax at closing if I'm doing an exchange?
Many states withhold from nonresident sellers by default. Exchanges are exempt, but you must file the state's exemption form at or before closing to avoid withholding.
Can I 1031 exchange U.S. property for property abroad?
No. Foreign real property is not like-kind with U.S. real property. Foreign-for-foreign exchanges are permitted, but U.S.-for-foreign is not.
Moving equity to another state?
I handle exchanges in all 50 states. Let's line up the withholding forms and the target-market broker before you close.
See If I Qualify